UK-Moscow extradition case overshadowed by mysterious death of Russian businessman’s mother

By Nataliya Vasilyeva, AP
Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Mother’s death overshadows UK extradition case

MOSCOW — A high-profile extradition case between London and Moscow has taken a surprise pause amid an investigation into the mysterious death of a Russian millionaire’s mother, who was found covered in blood in her Moscow apartment.

A London court on Monday postponed a hearing into the extradition of Yevgeny Chichvarkin, a 35-year-old businessman who insists he should not be sent back to Russia because someone has murdered his mother and his own life is in danger.

On Tuesday, Russian prosecutors announced a fresh probe into the April 3 death of 60-year-old Lyudmila Chichvarkina, the businessman’s lawyer in Moscow said. Chichvarkina was covered in blood and bruised when she was found but paramedics ruled that she died of a heart attack.

“There was clear evidence of an attempted murder,” lawyer Vladimir Zherebenkov told the Associated Press on Tuesday, saying her body was bruised all over as if she was severely beaten and her clothes and shoes were drenched in blood from head to toe.

It would have been a natural death only if “she had struck herself in the head twice and fell to the ground twenty times,” he added.

Chichvarkin also insists that his mother was murdered, citing his father’s visit to the crime scene and evidence in police files. He also says the extradition request by Russia is politically motivated because he had spoken out against corruption in Russia’s police force.

The murder mystery might prove to be a major factor in the London court’s decision whether Britain should extradite Chichvarkin back to Russia to face kidnapping charges. His lawyer says if Chichvarkin’s suspicions are proven, Russia’s case for his extradition will collapse.

Officials tried to cover up this case, Zherebenkov said, because “if evidence that she was murdered was made public, extradition would be dismissed right away.”

A spokeswoman for Moscow’s prosecutors’ office was not available to comment on the case Tuesday.

But Russian authorities appeared to have made a sharp turnaround since April, when the Investigative Committee, Russia’s chief investigative body, said it would not conduct a probe because there were no signs of a violent death.

Investigators first claimed that Chichvarkina had bruised herself when she bumped her head against the edge of the kitchen table, but Moscow chief investigator Anatoly Bagmet admitted in June that she had been beaten up. However, he did not order a probe at the time, saying the beating could not have caused the death.

It was not clear why a new probe was ordered, but Britain is not likely to extradite a suspect while there are questions about a possible violent death in his immediate family.

Chichvarkin, one of Russia’s most successful businessman during the early 2000s, did not make his fortune in commodities like most Russian millionaires. He started in 1997 at age 22 selling mobile phones in a firm that later became Russia’s largest mobile phone retailer.

Known for his eccentric style and colorful language, he made the company Yevroset a household name in Russia thanks to its aggressive and often risque marketing. But he was also well-known for outspoken statements against corruption in Russia’s police forces, which he says prompted the charges against him.

Yevroset came under attack in the fall of 2008 when one of his deputies was arrested and charged with kidnapping and extortion.

Prosecutors said a Yevroset vice president and his subordinates kidnapped a shipping agent who they suspected of stealing a large number of handsets. They allegedly kept him in an apartment in a Moscow suburb, demanding that he pay them 10 million rubles ($334,000) — the alleged value of the handsets he had stolen.

Chichvarkin fled Russia in December 2008. A month later a Moscow court charged him in absentia with complicity in the kidnapping and put out an international arrest warrant.

Chichvarkin says the charges are a complete fabrication from a police department that was seeking revenge for his efforts to expose corruption.

The Yevroset kidnapping trial is due to start later this month in Moscow, and the London court will watch it closely to see whether these charges have any grounds, Chichvarkin’s lawyer said.

“There is a lot of evidence that prosecutors are trying to hide,” Zherebenkov said. “Economic and political motives behind this case are evident.”

will not be displayed