New York AG filing civil charges saying Bank of America, former CEO Lewis misled investors

New York AG filing civil charges against BofA

NEW YORK — The New York Attorney General’s office said Thursday it filed civil charges against Bank of America and its former CEO Ken Lewis, saying the bank misled investors about Merrill Lynch before it acquired the Wall Street bank in early 2009.

Civil charges were also being filed against Joe Price, who was chief financial officer at the time of the deal and is now head of BofA’s consumer banking division.

At the same time Attorney General Andrew Cuomo’s office was filing its civil charges, the Securities and Exchange Commission reached a settlement to resolve federal charges it brought against the bank over similar issues. It is the second time the SEC and Bank of America have tried to settle that case.

Bank of America has been accused of failing to properly disclose losses at Merrill and bonuses paid to investment bank employees before the deal closed. Cuomo called Bank of America’s actions “egregious and reprehensible” in deceiving shareholders and the federal government.

The bank, Lewis and Price are facing charges under New York’s Martin Act, a wide-ranging securities law that is aimed at fighting fraud. The charges by Cuomo’s office lay the blame for additional government bailouts and alleged deception on the top executives at the nation’s largest bank.

Cuomo’s use of the Martin Act could be problematic for Lewis and Price. Unlike federal securities law, the Martin Act doesn’t require proving any intent to defraud shareholders, said John C. Coffee, a Columbia Law School professor specializing in corporate governance and securities law.

“You merely have to show that these individuals were responsible for materially false disclosures made to investors,” Coffee said. “It’s somewhat more threatening” than federal law.

It is unclear how big any potential fines would be if the bank or executives lose the case. Because it is a civil charge, there is no possibility of jail time.

Bank of America received an additional $20 billion in government bailout funds in January 2009 to help offset losses it absorbed as part of the Merrill Lynch acquisition. In December, Bank of America repaid the $20 billion, plus the initial $25 billion it received in government bailout money.

Lewis stepped down as CEO from Bank of America Corp. on Dec. 31 after almost a year of strife that followed the bank’s purchase of Merrill Lynch. Price became head of the bank’s consumer banking division, taking over for Brian Moynihan, who succeeded Lewis as CEO on Jan. 1.

Moynihan is not under investigation.

Cuomo’s office claims Bank of America intentionally misled shareholders about the more than $15 billion in losses Merrill recorded in the fourth quarter of 2008 to get the deal completed. Bank of America also hid $3.6 billion in year-end bonuses Merrill employees received as it asked its share holders to approve the deal, the suit alleges.

Bank of America then used the mounting losses to force the government to provide it with the additional $20 billion in bailout money, the lawsuit claims. Lewis has testified before Congress that he was forced by government regulators to complete the deal, even though he had trepidation about doing so.

Richard W. Painter, a law professor at the University of Minnesota and an expert on securities fraud, said the federal government’s role in the merger makes the case particularly tricky.

If the Treasury or regulators were aware of any misrepresentation to Bank of America shareholders, then Cuomo will in effect be going after Lewis, Price and the bank “with the federal government as an accomplice,” Painter said.

“The question is going to be: Where was the government when all this is going down and is anyone going to hold the government accountable if they did sign off on this?” he added.

Bank of America spokesman Robert Stickler said: “We are disappointed and find it regrettable that the NY AG has chosen to file these charges, which we believe are totally without merit.

“The evidence demonstrates that Bank of America and its executives, including Ken Lewis and Joe Price, at all times acted in good faith and consistent with their legal and fiduciary obligations. In fact, the SEC had access to the same evidence as the NYAG and concluded that there was no basis to enter either a charge of fraud or to charge individuals.”

Mary Jo White, Lewis’ attorney, said in a statement that Cuomo’s decision to sue was “a badly misguided decision without support in the facts or the law.” Lawyers for Price said the attorney general’s allegations were “flatly contrary to the evidence.”

Tony Plath, a finance professor at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte, said the charges create a “serious distraction for the future of the business.”

Bank of America did agree to pay $150 million to shareholders to settle the SEC charges. The agreement still must be approved by U.S. District Judge Jed S. Rakoff.

In September, the bank and the government agreed to a $33 million settlement only to have Rakoff reject the agreement.

Stickler confirmed that the bank won’t not be going to trial with the SEC on their charges, assuming the settlement is approved. The trial was scheduled for March 1.

Rakoff called the first deal a breach of “justice and morality” and ordered the case to go to trial. Rakoff wrote that the $33 million settlement was “done at the expense, not only of the shareholders, but also of the truth.”

A hearing about the new settlement is scheduled for Monday afternoon.

_____

Augstums reported from Charlotte, N.C. AP Business Writer Stevenson Jacobs and Associated Press writer Larry Neumeister in New York contributed to this report.