Jury finds Cornell student guilty of murder for slashing wife’s throat on NY nature trail

Jury: Cornell student guilty of murdering wife

ITHACA, N.Y. — A Cornell University doctoral student from New Zealand who says a mental disorder made him think his wife had been replaced by an impostor was convicted of murder Tuesday for slashing her throat on a park trail in central New York and torching their home to destroy evidence.

After eight hours of deliberations over two days, a jury found Blazej Kot, 25, guilty of murder, arson and tampering with physical evidence.

Kot, who showed no emotion as the verdict was read, could draw 25 years to life in prison for killing Caroline Coffey, a postdoctoral researcher at the Ivy League school. He’s set to be sentenced on May 25.

The defense wanted the murder charge reduced to manslaughter, arguing Kot suffered from paranoia and other acute symptoms associated with Capgras delusion, a misidentification syndrome common in patients diagnosed with schizophrenia.

After a three-week trial, prosecutor Andrew McElwee dismissed Kot’s justification for killing his wife of eight months as a ludicrous attempt to elude blame for a premeditated murder carried out simply to end an unhappy relationship.

“The defense wants it to be fantastical,” McElwee said in closing arguments Monday. “The simplest explanation is true — the defendant was unhappy with his life.”

Defense psychiatrist Dr. Rory Houghtalen said Kot suffered from a personality disorder that made him fear he was being tested by unseen forces, leading him to believe he could only end the conspiracy by killing Coffey, whom he believed was a lookalike.

While Kot admitted killing her, prosecutors said his attempt to destroy physical evidence contradicted the notion he was propelled by an “extreme emotional disturbance.”

Coffey, 28, was killed a few hundred yards from their apartment last June on a trail popular with bikers and joggers in Ithaca’s rural outskirts. Soon afterward, Kot led police on a high-speed chase when a state park officer spotted him in a parked car with dried blood on his arms. During the five-mile chase, Kot critically wounded himself by cutting his throat with a knife.

Kot and Coffey met at Cornell and were married in Ithaca in October 2008 but saved up for an “exotic location” wedding ceremony in Costa Rica last May.

By then, however, Kot had taken a leave of absence from his doctoral program to work for a business startup. His 60-to-80-hour work weeks and the couple’s mounting financial woes were contributing to an onset of depression, paranoia and other symptoms, the defense said.