Indian town in Ecuador drops death penalty in murder, orders farm work for youthful defendant

Indian town drops death penalty in murder case

QUITO, Ecuador — An Indian community that sentenced a young man to death by hanging for the murder of another man softened his punishment Sunday, ordering him to do five years of community service instead.

Orlando Quishpe, 21, was also subjected to punishments that included carrying a heavy sack of dirt, an ice-water bath and a public whipping with a thorny plant while he was forced to beg forgiveness.

Ecuador’s attorney general had threatened legal action against the community after it ordered Quishpe’s execution last week, because the South American nation does not allow the death penalty.

The Indians refused the government’s request that the suspect be handed over to the regular courts. Ecuador’s constitution recognizes indigenous justice as long as it does not violate the charter or human rights.

An assembly of residents in La Cocha, about 55 miles (90 kilometers) from the capital, debated for six hours Sunday and dropped the death penalty.

They decided Quishpe will carry out “five years of work in the field,” community leader Ricardo Chaluisa told reporters. He said the work would be supervised by members of Quishpe’s home community, Guantopolo.

Before he was turned over to leaders from Guantopolo, Quishpe, who works as a carpenter and is in a rock band, underwent a day of punishment.

Nearly naked, he first was made to hold a sack of dirt for 10 minutes. Tied to a whipping post, he was doused in an icy bath and beaten with nettles while he apologized to the townspeople — although he denied any guilt in the slaying of Marco Olivo, 21.

Olivo was beaten and then hanged with a belt on May 9. Town leaders accused Quishpe of using his belt in the killing. No motive for the attack has been released.

Four other young men underwent a day of punishment for the crime a week ago. The community said they confessed to participating in the attack.