Malaysia refuses to prosecute 2 Muslims who deceived Catholic church, took Communion

Malaysia won’t punish Muslims for taking Communion

KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia — Malaysia won’t prosecute two Muslims who pretended to be Roman Catholics and took Communion, a decision a church leader said Thursday undermines peace at a time of rising tensions between Muslims and the country’s religious minorities.

“The lack of action would appear to legitimize” the behavior of the two men, said Archbishop Murphy Pakiam of Kuala Lumpur, who heads the Roman Catholic Church in peninsular Malaysia.

In a letter dated Feb. 12, Malaysian police informed the church that, following instructions from the attorney-general’s office, “no further action” would be taken against two men who were investigated after they pretended to be Christians and took Communion at a church service to research a magazine article.

The monthly Malay-language Al-Islam magazine indicated the men spat out the Communion wafers because they took a photograph of it partially bitten. Catholics believe the Communion wafer is transformed into the body of Christ by the priest during the Mass.

The crime of causing religious disharmony carries a prison term of up to five years in Malaysia. The government stance in this case is likely to draw comparisons with its strong defense of Islam, the faith of the majority of Malaysia’s 28 million people.

Most prominently, it has vigorously defended a ban on non-Muslim use of the word Allah. Court rulings in inter-religious disputes generally favor Muslims, and government leaders have on occasion publicly brandished daggers, vowing to defend Islam with their blood.

Attorney General Abdul Gani Patail said in a statement that he decided not to prosecute the two men because “they did not intend to offend anyone. It was an act of sheer ignorance.”

He added that he had made the same decision in “previous cases where the circumstances were quite similar involving other religions.”

One of the men who attended the church service wrote in the magazine that he found no evidence to support rumors that Muslim teenagers were being converted to Christianity in churches. He described how he and his unnamed companion tasted Communion wafers to blend in with the crowd.

Non-baptized persons are not allowed to receive Communion in the Catholic church. While the church allows non-Catholics to attend Mass, many Catholics in this case were unhappy the two men entered the church under false pretenses.

Pakiam urged the government to rethink its position and file criminal charges against the two men, but the church would not sue the magazine. “We hope and pray. That’s our religious approach,” the archbishop said.

However, the church would cease to pressure the government if the magazine makes a formal apology, he said. “Forgiveness is the main line in our blood,” he said.